âHYAAAAAH!!â
Harper shrieks and takes a frog-legged leap off the couch in my office and sends her stuffed animal into a dramatic, slow-motion somersault. She plops the giraffe on my desk. The computer monitor shakes in front of me.
She wiggles his long, floppy legs, making ninja noises in my general direction.
I donât know where Nadia is. I try to make a point of not knowing. We may have shared a bed last night, but we didnât speak. I didnât join her until late, when she was already asleepâor pretending to sleepâand I left long before she woke up.
But I did sleep for those few hours, with her body next to mine, stretched out in the dark. Deep and blissful sleep. Finally, finally .
Maybe thatâs why I weather being socked in the head by a stuffed giraffe better than expected.
The girl has followed me all morning. She spends most of her time asking what Iâm doing, and then asking why Iâm doing it, and then asking how Iâm doing it, and then asking why Iâm doing it the way Iâm doing it.
She might have a promising future in mid-level management.
âApplesauce knows karate,â Harper informs me, as the words on the screen slip in and out of focus.
âI thought he was a doctor,â I mutter, half-listening.
âDoctors can know karate. Applesauce can do a lot of things! What do you do?â she asks, standing on her tiptoes to look over my desk, like she might find the answer there.
ââ¦Thatâs complicated.â
âMommy calls people on the phone,â she tells me, very proudly.
âNot anymore she doesnât.â
âWhy not?â
âBecause itâs beneath her. And she doesnât need to.â
Harper doesnât seem to understand, but she lets it go and says instead, âWhen I get big, Iâm going to be a nurse.â
âNot a doctor?â
âNo, because doctorsâdoctorsââ she scrunches up her face, trying to figure out a reason, âDoctors are good, but nurses are all really nice, and they can wear cartoon characters on their clothes,â she informs me, then keeps chattering on and on about how much she likes nurses. I get a small idea of what her life has been like up to this point, the experiences that have shaped her tiny little worldview.
She climbs back up onto the couch for another round of interrogation.
âWhat are you again?â she asks. I study her, wondering what sheâs looking for. What she could even understand about the things I do. How do you condense something like that for a child? I study the email on the screen, the dot-gov extension filling up the recipient line.
âIâm a bad guy,â I tell her.
She giggles. âNo, youâre not,â she says, like Iâm just messing with her.
âI am.â
She shakes her head, refusing to believe me, her baby teeth grin bright and infectious.
âUh-uh. You canât be a bad guy or Applesauce would beat you up.â
âApplesauce has already beaten me up a few times this morning,â I remind her, and she immediately jumps off the couch again and goes running around the office, giggling and yelling something about how Applesauce is also a superhero who can fly and beat up bad guys, her feet pounding on the floor, her voice pitched and breathy as she shows me.
Olivia chooses this moment to come angrily sweeping in with a tray, eyebrows furrowed in bewildered outrage at the chaos. Her question is half out of her lips at the same moment Harper zips across the doorway and gets tangled up under her feet. Olivia stumbles, spilling the contents of the tray everywhere across the carpet in a shattering crash.
â What the hell? â she snaps.
Food and drink go flying. Broken glass glistens under the light.
Harper stands frozen, wide-eyed under her.
âWhy are you in here?â Olivia demands, reaching down to take Harper by the wrist.
âDonât touch that girl.â
My voice snaps and freezes her in place. She has one hand around Harperâs arm, staring at me like Iâve gone mad.
âMr. Caruso, if sheâs bothering you, you should let meââ
â Youâre bothering me,â I say. âGet out of my office and donât make the mistake of touching her again.â
Olivia makes a motion to the coffee seeping into the carpet, âWell, do you want me to at leastââ
âI said out!â I bellow, getting to my feet.
Olivia goes without another word, sweeping out and leaving a tense silence behind.
Harper stands frozen, staring at the stain seeping toward her feet, the giraffe clutched to her chest. Sheâs on the verge of tears. âI didnât mean toââ
âShe wasnât looking where she was going.â
Harper moves to try and pick some of the mess up, but I sweep her up onto the couch, away from the shards of glass.
âSit,â I order her, and this time, my tone makes her curl her stuffie to her chest and stay put.
Footsteps come bounding up the stairs two at a time and Nadia appears in the doorway.
âWhat happened? I thought she was in her bedroomââ
âOliviaâs clumsy and needs to watch where sheâs going.â
Harperâs guilty silence doesnât back up my story, but it doesnât matter. If I say something happened a certain way, then thatâs how it happened. In this house, I decide what is and what isnât.
Nadia drops down across from me, helping pile pieces of glass and scattered food onto the tray. Our hands brush and we both pretend they didnât.
âHow long has she been up here?â
âAs long as I have.â
Nadia shakes her head with a wince. âShe left the TV on, so I thoughtâI mean, sheâs always glued to the TV when I let her, so I didnât think sheâd go anywhere. Sheâs never had anywhere to wander off to before.â
âShe didnât do anything.â
Nadia must have heard something because I can see that she doesnât believe me. But she doesnât press it.
âReally, she should be in school,â she sighs, âUnless she isnât going to school anymore.â She searches my face, as if thatâs somehow my concern.
âHow you raise your daughter isnât my business.â
She huffs slightly under her breath. âIâm having a hard time figuring out what is and isnât your businessâ¦â
âIâm happy to clarify any questions,â I counter.
âHow generous.â Her smile clenches.
We finish picking up slivers of glass without looking at each other again. âIâll get her out of your hair. Take her out and burn off some of that energy. Harper, go put some outside clothes on, please. Weâre going out for a while.â
âCan Ren come?â she asks. She sounds almost hopeful. I donât know why.
The room plunges into cold silence.
âIâm sure Ren has better things to doââ
âIâll join you,â I interrupt, before she can make the decision for me. Nadia stares at me, her mouth tight, as Harper celebrates. I take the tray out of Nadiaâs hands and head downstairs, feeling her eyes following me as I go.
***
Harper gets free rein on where she would like to go. Anywhere at all. On her request, we take a car over to Battery Park, where thereâs some carousel she wants to ride, and which she talks about endlessly on the ride over. She wants to ride all by herself this timeâor at least, her and her giraffe.
Nadia lets Harper do the talking, keeping a cold shoulder toward me as we drive.
âYou didnât used to be this quiet,â I remark as Nadia and I walk side by side into the park. Harper skips ahead of us.
âThings change,â she says, keeping her eyes forward and her steps quick. I match her pace, my long strides an easy advantage.
âIf things change, then they can change back.â
âYou want me to talk to you? Fine. Why are you out here with us, Ren?â she finally asks, quieter now that Harper isnât within listening range.
âAm I not allowed to spend time with my wife?â I ask, the words warm against her ear as we walk too close to each other. Her silence goes up like a brick wall. Not convincing. âYou clearly have something to say, Nadia; you may as well say it.â
âI have plenty to say. I just have enough common sense not to.â
I slide my hand against Nadiaâs lower back. Tension tightens up her spine. Under my touch, her posture is immaculate, unease radiating like an aura. She has the good sense not to step away and lets my touch guide her along our route.
Harper bounces in place as she waits at the gate.
âIs there other stuff we can do, too?â she asks, breathless, like the world has cracked open like an oyster. âLike the slide?â
âOf course.â
âI didnât know you had such an open schedule,â Nadia remarks.
âI can make time where needed.â
I slip my hand into hers, squeezing against her slack, empty grip. A firm reminder that I am not going anywhere. I bring the back of her hand to my lips to kiss, the way couples do. The taste of her warm, soft skin sets my blood on fire. She shudders and yanks her hand away, leaving me with my teeth bared.
Being with her makes me half mad.
Being without her makes me fully mad. I guess this is what they call a step in the right direction.
âOnce Harper has tired herself out, where do you want to go?â I ask Nadia.
She scoffs like Iâm joking.
âThat isnât an answer.â
âBecause it isnât a real question,â she says, cradling her hand like Iâve hurt it.
âOf course it is.â
âOh, sure. I want to go to a show, and a six-course dinner, and a club, with a new outfit for each.â
âAlright.â
She turns to face me so fast, I think she might actually hit me. I donât flinch. Iâm bigger, used to pain, and more importantly, angrier than Nadia can ever be. Even if she swung at me, I wouldnât feel a damn thing. But she doesnât hit me with anything except an exasperated glare, like Iâm taunting her or insulting her. Sheâs like a wounded animal. Everything I do, she regards with suspicion.
I know what kind of man I am, and it isnât good.
But I also know what kind of man Iâm not.
âI donât want to do anything,â she finally mutters, turning away from me when I donât flinch.
God, she hates me.
Weâve drawn close to the front of the line. I hold out my credit card, dangling it like a counterpoint in our silent argument. She swallows her anger as she takes it, her expression saying all the things her mouth wonât. She walks Harper down to the carousel, then comes back to stand with me at the exit gate.
âWhatâs the point of a carousel you can barely see your child riding?â I ask, the sun glinting into my eyes from the enclosed ride.
âIt looks better at night,â she mutters. Muffled music drones from inside the ride. There are a lot of people here, and even in the spring, the weather feels uncomfortably warm for the season.
ââ¦You said you were going to marry me as a punishment,â she finally says, quietly, under the chatter of the crowd and squeals of the children around us. âIs all of this part of my punishment somehow?â
âDo you want me to be here?â I ask.
She doesnât answerâbut she doesnât have to. I already know what the answer is.
âThen itâs a punishment. Itâs all punishment.â
She shakes her head, her jaw tight, arms crossed. She wonât let me see her face again as we wait, the minutes passing as the ride goes on and on, around and around.
Harper comes out of the ride, looking around for us as parents and children swarm together. Nadia steps forward to get her, but I whistle around my fingers, sharp and piercing. It draws eyesâbut more importantly, draws Harperâs, and she smiles at me and comes running, rushing right past her mother.
â Again? â she asks and throws her arms around my legs.
Those big eyes look up at me, full of hope and excitement for something so simple .
âAgain.â
I do a double-take as I catch Nadiaâs expression out of the corner of my eye. Sheâs trying to be discreet about wiping off her cheeks, trying to hide the tears. I donât know what theyâre from. Anger. Frustration. Despair. I pretend not to notice.
I take Harper to the back of the line, and this time, Harper asks me to ride with her. Nadia doesnât say a word.