CHAPTER TWENTY-SIX – The Truth

Andrew’s POV

Under the influence of Logan’s order, Sienna had to tell us everything. Every word she said to Emma, everything she did. I felt like I was standing there, watching.

With every word that came out of her mouth, my urge to kill her grew.

When she told us that she had told Emma that I thought she was a burden, I lost it.

“You. Said. WHAT?” I growled through my teeth.

’LET ME OUT, ANDREW!’ Asher screamed in my head, clawing to get out.

‘I AM GOING TO KILL HER!’ Asher growled.

‘Not yet, Asher!’ I screamed at him. ‘She has to tell us where Emma is first.’

I walked up to Sienna. She was struggling against Logan’s order, and she was only making it more painful for herself. She was wincing in pain, and I was enjoying it.

I kneeled in front of her and got in her face. It took all my strength not to dip my fangs into her throat and rip it out.

“If she believed what you said, I will kill you so slowly you will be begging me to die,” I said slowly.

She winced, but a moment later I saw her smirk.

“If she believed me, it is your fault,” she said. “You were a terrible brother. She tried to tell you about me so many times. You never believed her, and everything she said was true.”

I growled and went to grab her neck, but before I could, Drake pulled me back.

“Not yet, Andrew,” he said, holding me back.

I ran my fingers through my hair.

She was right. I was a terrible brother. I chose to believe Sienna over my own sister. I didn’t want to believe that my friend, the person I grew up with, could do that. I always thought that Emma was jealous. Logan, Sienna, and I were always together. We were older than Emma was, and we had different interests and topics. And when Logan and I took over the pack, we became even closer and busier, always doing what the pack needed. Sienna was always there to support us, and she always understood everything. I just thought Emma wanted to spend more time with me, and she was angry she couldn’t. I just thought that Sienna being around all the time made her jealous. It made sense at the time.

Now I see how wrong I was.

And my mistake hurt my sister. My pup.

Logan intensified the order, and Sienna cried out.

“Continue talking, bitch,” Logan growled.

He hasn’t said a word since Sienna started talking, but I saw he was on the edge. Asher told me Leon was completely unhinged. I had no idea how Logan managed to control him.

Sienna continued talking. She told us how she told Emma that Logan hated her and how he would think she betrayed the pack by becoming a rogue.

Logan started shaking, but he didn’t lose it as I did. Once he did, Goddess help Sienna. He would rip her apart.

And I would help him.

She proceeded to tell us how that filthy rogue wolf stabbed a needle full of wolfsbane into Emma’s neck, and she fainted.

After that, the rogue hit Sienna so she could sell her lie about Emma hitting her and running away.

He took Emma away, and Sienna waited three hours before she tried to mind-link Logan.

“Where is Emma?” Logan growled and increased the intensity of his order.

“I don’t know,” Sienna whimpered.

What?

I froze.

She didn’t know?

Logan, Drake, and I exchanged worried glances.

“Sienna, don’t make me torture you,” Logan growled, turning back to her. “Where is she?”

“I swear I don’t know.” she cried out. “Rogue said he would hide her well. He told me there was a cave well hidden on the north side of the forest. But I don’t know where it is exactly.”

“How the hell were you two supposed to exchange information?” Logan growled, clenching his fists.

“He said that he would come to find me,” she said.

“When?” I asked.

“I don’t know,” she said. “We didn’t set a date on purpose. I thought it would be best to not know. If I was ever caught, like I am now, I didn’t want to make it easy for you.”

She smirked, and the three of us lost it.

We growled so loudly that the entire room shook.

Sienna covered her ears and whimpered.

Fuck. How the hell were we going to find her? That area was huge.

“How the hell did a rogue get on my territory?” Logan asked Sienna.

“Oh, please.” she rolled her eyes. “I know everything about patrols and shifts. It was easy to get him in here without them noticing. That’s how I have been getting out of the territory as well. I had to find a wolf willing to help me. And Rolf was more than willing to after he saw Emma.”

Asher growled loudly.

“You are such a bitch, Sienna,” Drake said.

“Why did you do all that?” I asked. “What has Emma ever done to you?”

She narrowed her eyes at me and growled.

“Are you kidding me?” she said through her teeth. “Little Miss Perfect had everything. The two of you always protected her and loved her. You never protected or loved me the way you did her. And after it turned out Logan wasn’t my mate, my gut told me he would be hers. I thought I would be okay with that if you, Andrew, turned out to be my mate. You would finally love me more than her. But it turned out you were not my mate, Andrew. And when I found out that Logan and Emma really were mates, I lost it. She had to go. I realized that as long as she was in our lives, you would never love me like you are supposed to.”

Goddess. I had no idea what to tell her. She was completely insane.

Logan was just staring at her, and I could tell he was as speechless as I was.

“I did it for us,” Sienna said seriously. “I did it for our love. I am better than her for you. You will see that now that she is out of our lives.”

“You have completely lost it,” I whispered in disbelief.

“I am done listening to you,” Logan growled. “I am going to find her, and after I do, I will kill you. I won’t do it now because I want you to see her coming home. I want you to see her safe and protected. Then you will die.”

Logan walked to the door, and Drake and I started following him.

Sienna growled. “No! I am better than her! She will never come back! Never! She will die!”

We walked out of the room, and Logan told the guard to chain Sienna to the chair.

The guard quickly left to follow his Alpha’s order.

After he came back, Logan locked the door and placed the key inside his pocket.

“Nobody comes in here but me,” Logan ordered the guard.

We quickly left the cellar and headed toward Logan’s office to plan our search.