Chapter 156
The Hockey Star’s Remorse
With the day trip to the spa scheduled, I decided it was time to start packing, though my mind was weighed down by the heavy
tension that had enveloped our apartment. Aria had been avoiding me ever since our fight, and I couldnât help but feel like i was
walking on eggshells.
I began folding clothes and carefully selecting toiletries to take with me when I heard a sharp knock at my bedroom door. Before I
could answer, Aria barged in, a sheet of paper clutched tightly in her hand. The look on her face was a mixture of concern and
anger, a storm brewing behind her eyes.
âWhat's this?â Aria demanded, thrusting the paper toward me. I took it from her and my heart sank as I realized what it was the
protective order Stella had filed against me.
âWhat are you doing with this?â I asked, my voice betraying my unease.
Ariaâs voice was tight with frustration as she replied, âI found it on the kitchen counter, Evie. Why didnât you tell me about this?â
I sighed, frustration bubbling up inside me. âItâs nothing. Aria. I didnât want to bother you with my messy life anymore.â
Ariaâs eyebrows furrowed as she studied me, clearly not buying my dismissive attitude. âIt doesnât look like ânothing. Evie. Stella
filed a protective order against you. You should have told me.â
I turned away from her, feeling a mix of embarrassment and guilt. âI didnât want to burden you with my problems, Aria, Besides,
what could you have done about it?â
Ariaâs voice grew exasperated. âWhat could I have done? Well, for starters, I could have been there for you, supported you.
We're supposed to be friends, Evie!â
I clenched my fists, my anger building. âLook, itâs my problem to deal with.â
Ariaâs frustration boiled over, and she took a step closer to me, her voice rising. âI spoke to Lucas about the trip, and he told me
that Stella had threatened you. You got him involved, but not me?
I threw my hands up in exasperation. âI didnât want to make a big deal out of it. I thought I could handle it on my own.
Ill
Ariaâs anger flared, and she practically shouted, âWell, you canât handle it on your own! Stella is clearly dangerous!â
I was at my breaking point, exhausted from the constant turmoil that had my life. âAria, Iâm not in the mood to fight with you right
now.
consumed
Ariaâs eyes bore into mine, but there was a hint of hurt in her voice when she spoke. again. âIs that how itâs going to be, Evie?
You're just not going to speak to me anymore?â
I didnât have the energy for this argument. My shoulders slumped, and I admitted defeat. âI just need some space right now.â
With a frustrated huff, Aria stormed out of my room, leaving me alone with my thoughts and a heavy sense of guilt. I knew I
should have confided in her about the order, but I had been so wrapped up in my own fears and insecurities that I hadnât
considered how it might affect her.
The hours passed, and I tried to push aside the nagging worry that gnawed at me. I finished packing, doubleâchecking that I had
everything I needed for the spa trip. It was supposed to be a day of relaxation and rejuvenation, but it felt like an impossible task
with the weight of my problems hanging over me.
The streetlights flickered to life as I made my way through the dimly lit streets of downtown. After packing my suitcase for the spa
trip. I had arranged to meet Penny for a late-night breakfast at the nearby diner. The promise of comfort food and her company
offered a glimmer of solace.
The bell above the dinerâs door tinkled as I stepped inside, and the scent of sizzling bacon and freshly brewed coffee enveloped
me. Penny sat in a corner booth. nursing a cup of coffee, her expression peaceful. As I slid into the booth across from her, I
could already sense that the conversation ahead wouldnât be an easy
I picked up a menu, but my appetite had vanished beneath the weight of my worries. âYou won't believe what happened today.â I
began, my voice quivering.
Penny looked at me intently, her bright eyes filled with curiosity. âSpill it, Evie. What's going on?â
111
Chapter 156
I took a deep breath, my anger bubbling just beneath the surface. âStella framed me for tearing up her wedding dress, Penny.
She made it look like I did it and then filed a protective order against me.â
Penny's face twisted into a scowl, her anger mirroring my own. âThat conniving witch! Why would she do something like that?â
I lowered my head, feeling a heavy weight on my chest. âMay have something to do with those photos...â
Penny tapped her fingers on the table, deep in thought. âYou know, Evie, Stella has made a lot of enemies over the years. Sheâs
not exactly the most liked person in town. Maybe someone else had a vendetta against her.â
I frowned, considering Pennyâs words. âBut who would hate her enough to go to such lengths? Tear up her dress, have her frame
me, and then file a protective order? Itâs all so calculated.â
Pennyâs eyes narrowed in thought. âHer sister Scarlett hates her right? And she was at the Hayes mansion that day when the
dress was torn, and might have been there earlier to tear it.â
The mention of Scarlett made my heart race. Scarlettâs sudden appearance had always struck me as odd. She had shown up
and asked for my help specifically while also nursing an intense dislike of Stella.
I nodded slowly, a sinking feeling settling in my stomach. âI would hope itâs not her.â
Penny leaned in, her voice lowered to a conspiratorial whisper. âWhat if Scarlett had something to do with it? She might have a
vendetta against Stella, and this would be the perfect way to get back at her.â
The idea sent shivers down my spine. Accusing her of something so serious without concrete evidence seemed reckless.
âI donât know, Penny,â I replied, my voice uncertain. âShe seems classier than that.â
Penny sighed, frustration evident in her eyes. âClassy people are usually the messiest behind closed doors, but says itâs not her?
Maybe Linda?â
I blinked wildly. That wasnât a name I'd heard in a while. âLinda...1 guess she would hate the woman marrying Timothy. She hated
me just for working with him.â
A
âRight!â Penny nodded rapidly, seeming more drawn to that conclusion.
I hunched over a table, the cheap Formica surface sticky with the residue of countless meals. I stabbed at my hash browns with
a fork, more out of habit than hunger, while Penny sipped her black coffee, her eyes darting around as if searching for something
that could never be found.
âPenny,â I began, breaking the silence, âIâve got to tell Timothy.â
Penny glanced up from her coffee, her eyebrows furrowing in concern. âTell him what?â
I hesitated for a moment, as if the very act of speaking the words aloud would make them all too real. âHe needs to know about
Stella and Andy.â
Penny's coffee cup clattered against the saucer as she set it down, her eyes, widening in shock. âBut you said...we agreed that-â
âIt's wrong,â I cut her off, leaning toward her. âKeeping it to ourselves isnât helping anyone, and looks so miserable. I canât let him
go through with that knowing that that woman doesnât value him.â
Pennyâs eyes remained fixed on me, her expression a mixture of sympathy and concern. âEvie, are you sure you want to do this?
I mean, telling Timothy... itâs a big step. You could be tearing his world apart.â
I sighed. âI know, but Timothy deserves to know the truth. Heâs planning to marry her, crying out loud. Heâs about to commit his
life to someone whoâs been betraying him with his own brother.â
Penny drummed her fingers on the table, deep in thought. âIf youâre so sure about this, Evie, than I guess you should tell him.â
I shook my head vigorously, a shiver running down my spine at the mere thought of Timothy falling apart because of me. âNo, no,
I canât have him hate me for this. It needs to look like itâs from someone else.â
Penny leaned in closer, her voice a conspiratorial whisper. âYou can send an anonymous email from a fake address, one that
canât be traced back to you.â
Aglimmer of hope flickered in my heart as I considered Penny's suggestion. It seemed like the perfect solution, a way to expose
the truth without sacrificing my friendship with Timothy. âThat might work, Penny.â
4/5
A
Chapter 136
Penny's lips curled into a sly grin as she grabbed her bag and set it on the table between us. She slipped out her thin laptop and
opened it. âDid you want to do it now? It'll be quick and painless.â
I bit my lip as the nerves gripped my gut. It would be quick surely, but the painless part was debatable.
âWe'll create an anonymous email address, send the evidence, and let the chips fall where they may,â she explained once more,
pushing the laptop in my direction.
After some hesitation, I agreed. With the plan in motion, we spent the next hour huddled over Pennyâs laptop in the dimly lit
corner of the diner, creating a fake email address and compiling the incriminating evidence.
As we finished crafting the email, Penny looked at me, her eyes filled with determination. âAre you absolutely sure about this,
Evie? Once we hit send, thereâs no turning back.â
I took a deep breath and nodded, my resolve unwavering. âMaybe schedule it for a certain day though, the day after tomorrow.â
Penny scheduled the send date and clicked the send button. After loading, the email disappeared into the digital abyss. We
watched in silence, the weight of our actions settling over us.
âThis is going to change everything, Evie,â Penny said.
âIt had to be done,â I told her, picking up my fork. My appetite still hadnât
returned. âTimothy deserves the truth, no matter what it costs.â
And I was prepared to bear the brunt of that cost.