Sidelined Love: Chapter 25

“God, I’ve been wanting to do that all evening,” I confess before my lips land back on hers. Hailey’s hands end up in my hair, pulling me closer to her. I went into this wondering where the night would lead, hoping we might be on the same page about where we wanted tonight to go. If she wants things to continue in the direction they seem to be going in, then great. If she wants to stop, that’s also fine.

I break our kiss and I never thought I would see the day when Hailey Reed began to whine, but I lose the fight with the chuckle that I’ve been struggling against. “I want to confirm that you’re okay with this, Rook.”

She bites her lip and nods shyly. “Yes, I’m okay with this.”

I smile because that’s all I need to hear. Her consent and being comfortable is my priority, but there’s something I need as well. “Take your hair down.”

“Why don’t you do it?” she asks with a smirk.

“You don’t have to tell me twice.” I reach up and gently tug at the silk band holding her hair in its messy bun. As it falls loose around her shoulders, I brush my fingers through the soft waves before my eyes land back on hers. “Much better,” I whisper before leaning in again.

I start to nibble my way down her neck, and she moans in response. I smell the same vanilla and citrusy aroma that I did the first time when she was interacting with me at Brewed Beginnings. It’s intoxicating, and I know it’s something I could smell for the rest of my life and never grow tired of.

I shift back slightly so I can help her remove the purple chess club sweater she wore over here tonight. Being able to see a touch of her stomach as she lifts up her arms is making my cock harder than it has ever been before.

What the hell kind of spell did she have over me?

I run my hands down her back and trace the delicate fabric of her bra. My light touches cause goosebumps to appear on her flesh, a hint that gives away what I’m doing to her body.

“Fuck, Levi,” she moans, pulling me closer to her.

“You don’t know how much I love the sound of that.”

“Why don’t you show me?” Her question sounds innocent, but there’s some bite in her words that comes across like she’s daring me.

There is no way I can deny her request. The challenge in her voice only encourages me to prove how fucking hot this could be between us.

How good we could be together.

I need to explore this. I hold back a growl of approval as I unclasp her bra and find myself staring at her tits. “You’re so fucking beautiful, Hailey,” I whisper against her skin. Her nipples are hard nubs under my gaze, and I can’t wait to get my mouth on them.

But first, there is somewhere else we need to go.

I bend down and toss Hailey over my shoulder. The second thing I didn’t expect her to do tonight was laugh and squeal. Her laugh takes me by surprise. Not only is it rare to hear, but it sounds like a melody I could listen to on repeat for the rest of my life.

“Levi! Put me down.”

“Your wish is my command.” I place her down on the bed and I refuse to lie and say I don’t enjoy watching her breasts jiggle as a result.

“There’s something I need to tell you.”

I pause at the foot of the bed and stare at Hailey before some words fall out of my mouth. “Are you a virgin?”

Hailey does a double take. “What? No. I was going to say I’ve never gotten off with a partner before.”

My eyes narrow because I’m not sure I heard her properly. “None of the people you’ve slept with have given you an orgasm?”

All she does is nod.

“That’s a fucking sin and it’s never happening again.”

I waste no time climbing onto the bed after her and my lips land on her jawline. I make sure to leave a trail of kisses along it. Even when she shivers beneath me as a result, I know that my job has only just begun.

“Do you want me to stop?” I ask, but it’s nothing more than me mumbling against her skin as I kiss my way down her collarbone.

“No, this is what I want,” she says, the words rushing out before a moan leaves her lips because I’ve reached her breasts. I lick around her nipple before sucking it into my mouth, feeling her gasp against my lips. Her taste is addictive, and it drives me crazy how responsive she is under my touch.

I make sure that I don’t leave her other nipple without attention for too long and use my fingers to play with it, bringing it to a stiff peak rather quickly. I bite down gently on the nipple I’ve been sucking on. She arches her back as if to get closer to my mouth, which only encourages me to suck and nibble harder.

Watching the look of pure bliss on her face makes my dick grow harder, but I fight to do anything else but serve her. She deserves all of this and more, and I’m willing to give it all to her.

My hand wanders down her stomach and past her waist, until I reach her cotton panties.

“If I would have known we were going to do this, I might have found something sexier,” she says as my eyes meet hers.

“You think I give a damn about what underwear you’re wearing? The only thing that matters is that they’re going to end up on my bedroom floor.”

I make my way up to my knees and just stare at her as she lays across my bed. I guess I’ve been staring at her for too long because she moves up onto her elbows and looks down at me.

“What are you doing?”

“Staring at your perfect body. Will you let me touch and taste your pussy? Please?”

The only answer I receive is in the form of a moan, letting me know I’ve said the words she wants to hear, so I continue.

“Does it turn you on, me begging on my knees to taste you?”

“Yes, it does, and yes you may.”

I slide my fingers under the edge of her panties, teasing her skin with more light touches. I know where she wants me to go as her body squirms in anticipation. I can’t help but smirk at her impatience just before my fingers finally make their way to the place she wants me most.

“Fuck, you’re so wet already.” I pause for a moment to look into her eyes. “And we’ve only just begun.”

I part her other lips with my fingers as I lean in to lick my way up one of her thighs. She tastes sweet, salty, and all mine. I want more.

Her underwear is another barrier that is keeping me from getting to all of her, so I take them off as quickly as possible. I’m left staring at her naked body, wondering how I got this lucky. “You’re so beautiful.”

I take a moment, letting my eyes roam over her body, drinking in the sight of her. A low groan escapes my lips as I lower my head, trailing kisses down her abdomen, each one causing her to shiver under me. I make sure to take my time, savoring every inch of her before I reach my destination.

Although I want to put my mouth on her, my fingers want to have their fun first. I run them up and down her slit twice before slipping my middle finger into her.

Her lips part as she moans and the sound that leaves her lips is like music to my ears. As we stare at each other, the connection we forge while I’m fingerfucking her is electric. And that’s before her body starts moving in perfect sync with my hand.

I’m determined to make her come on my hand first. It’s a travesty that she hasn’t had this experience before, but I can’t say I feel guilty about her first time having this be with me.

I add another finger to her pussy and once I brush against her G-spot, she almost loses it. She’s growing closer to the edge, and I can’t wait to see her fall over it.

I shift my body while not losing too much of the pace I’m keeping. My mouth makes its way to her pussy, and I inhale deeply, taking in the intoxicating scent that surrounds me. I give her several small licks, teasers for what is about to come until I make it my mission to devour her.

“You taste so damn good,” is all I can manage to say before I continue licking and sucking. My utmost priority is not to ignore her clit because I have no doubt in my mind that it will drive her wild.

“Oh fuck!” she screams, and I look up at her. “Don’t stop.”

I smile against her skin and debate whether to tease her about having manners but decide against it. Instead, I increase the pace I’ve set because all I want to do is watch this beautiful woman come undone just for me.

Her hips buck against my face as her hands find their way into my hair. The last thing I’m about to do is complain because I’ve thought about this very moment for weeks.

As I listen to her breathing speed up, I know she’s close to coming apart. I take a second to move away from her pussy and say, “Come for me, baby.” Then it’s as if I’ve never left because I’m right back on her.

There’s a short moment of silence before she explodes, and I make sure not to miss a drop of everything she’s willing to give me.

“That’s my good girl,” I say. Her pussy continues to clench around my fingers as she comes down from the high. I pull them out of her and hold them up to her lips. She hesitates for a moment before she licks them clean.

That is the second hottest thing I’ve ever seen. The first was watching Hailey as I gave her an orgasm, and I am determined to make sure that it wouldn’t be the last.

It takes Hailey a moment to catch her breath, but she sits up, leaning on her elbows and says, “I want to return the favor.”

“Not this time, Rook,” I let out a shaky breath. “If I feel your lips on me, this is going to be game over before we even begin.”

“Well come on then, Jamison,” she says.

I can’t help but smirk at her using my last name. “What do you want?”

“I want you to use you’re cock to fuck me until I can’t walk tomorrow.”

If it wasn’t obvious that Hailey wasn’t shy about demanding what she wanted before, then those words would have removed all doubt.

“That can be arranged.”

“Do you have a condom?” she asks as she watches me take off my shirt, her gaze burning a trail across my body.

I unbutton my jeans and unzip my fly. “I do and I’m clean. Crawl up toward the headboard and lay back down.”

She stares at me before she says, “I am too,” and to my surprise, she does what I say.

I stand there for a couple of seconds, watching as her ass and pussy are on full display for me as she moves before I pull off my jeans, followed by my boxer briefs. I can’t help but smirk as she stares at my cock in amazement without making a sound. If I’ve stunned her into silence, I’ll take it as a win. I follow her onto the bed and lean over to dig into my bedside drawer to grab the thing I just promised her I had.

I roll the condom on as Hailey opens her legs, giving me plenty of room to work with. But she has gone back to resting on her elbows.

“Lay back,” I tell her again and she does so without hesitation. “Fuck, I’ve created a masterpiece. If only you could see how pretty your pussy looks right now.”

A small blush appears on her cheeks at my words, which is kind of funny to me given what we’ve just done. Regardless, I feel grateful she’s chosen me to experience this with.

I position myself between her legs and without a second thought, I enter her. She gasps and I manage to stop myself from moving too quickly, for fear that I might be harming her.

“Am I hurting you?” I ask, wanting to make sure she’s comfortable.

“N-no. This feels amazing. Better yet it is amazing.”

I take that as my sign to sink into her, inch by inch. Every move I make causes new sensations to form in my body and I only crave more of her.

More of this.

More of us.

“Still feeling good?” I ask her and all she does is nod.

Not wasting any more time, I pull back before sinking into her body once more. “Fuck.” How is this real?

Her pussy has me and my cock in a chokehold. When I imagined this happening, I never expected it to be like this.

The walls of her pussy clench around me off and on, making it difficult to keep a rhythm. Yet I manage because my goal is to make sure she finds bliss again. Hailey’s eyes are half closed and the only thing she is focused on is the pleasure I’m giving her. It takes everything in me not to tell her that I love the look on her face.

When I change the pace I’ve been keeping to one that matches the way her body moves against mine, she lets out a loud moan, telling me I’ve made the right move. All of this is addicting, and there is no way I’ll get enough of the way she feels underneath me.

I stare at the way our bodies move in harmony. I thought she was beautiful from the moment I saw her for the first time, but those words run through my mind on repeat like a mantra.

I lean down and capture her lips for a brief kiss that doesn’t disrupt our movements. “You’re mine, Rook.” I’m slightly concerned about what her response will be to it, but I needed to say the words.

Her mouth forms into a perfect O-shape before answering, “I am.”

While there are still some things we need to work out, hearing her say those two little words rocks my entire world and spurs me to move faster.

A grin forms on my face when I watch her eyes roll back into her head. This is because of what I am doing to her, and I refuse to do anything half-assed.

I place my hands on her waist, allowing me to pull her down harder on my cock. Her small gasps and moans fill the room, and I can’t stop.

“Fuck, Hailey.”

“I’m going to come,” she rushes out in between trying to catch any semblance of her breath.

“Do it for me, baby. Come now.”

That’s all it takes for her to come apart once more, and fuck, it’s the hottest thing I’ve ever seen. The way her body reacts to the pleasure is everything and more. I feel myself about to lose control, and when it happens, I swear I’m seeing stars.

My roar of approval is the only warning I give before I shoot my load inside the condom. My shaft twitches as we both ride out the aftershocks of what we’ve just done.

“That was…” she starts, barely able to form the words.

“That was incredible,” I finish for her.

I pull out of her slowly, savoring the feeling of her body against mine one last time. Carefully, I dispose of the condom and walk into my bathroom where I prepare a warm washcloth. Once I clean her up, I lay down and gather Hailey in my arms. Having her resting her head on my chest and being able to touch her like this does something to me. It’s not about sex. It feels healing in a way, but I’m not sure what she’s healing me from, and I don’t dare question it.

“I still can’t stand you,” she says, and I can hear her breathlessness.

“Huh. Yet your body can.”

The silence that follows is interrupted by Hailey sitting up and slapping my chest before plopping back down.

I chuckle because of what she just did. “Any time you want to do that, day or night. Doesn’t even matter if I’m dead asleep.”

“Duly noted.”

“I meant what I said, Hailey,” I tell her once we’ve both caught our breath. “You’re mine.”

She looks up at me with those beautiful hazel eyes of hers and smiles. “I know,” she says simply. “And you’re mine.”

I chuckle and press a kiss to her forehead. “Damn right.”