Back
Chapter 37

0036|the ball

MY DADDYS BEST FRIEND||18+

ARABELLA ARMANI

The grand hall of the Castellano estate was alive with opulence and energy. Crystal chandeliers bathed the room in a warm, golden glow, their light bouncing off the marble floors. The air hummed with the low murmur of conversation and the soft strains of a live orchestra. Arabella adjusted the satin fabric of her emerald gown, the fitted bodice and flowing skirt making her feel like she belonged in a fairytale.

"Arabella, you look incredible," Theo said as he offered her his arm. He wore a sleek black tuxedo, and his usual shy demeanor had been replaced with a quiet confidence.

"Thank you," Arabella said with a smile. "And you clean up nicely yourself."

Sarah and Carter trailed behind them, Sarah in a shimmering silver dress that turned heads as they entered, and Carter in a deep navy suit with a matching pocket square.

"Remind me why I agreed to come to this?" Carter muttered playfully.

"Because I promised free champagne," Arabella replied with a grin.

The group made their way into the hall, where Emilio Castellano, Arabella's father, stood at the entrance, greeting guests with the practiced charm of a seasoned host. His presence was commanding, his tailored suit and sharp eyes reminding everyone of the power he wielded.

"Arabella," he said warmly, pulling her in for a brief kiss on the cheek. "You look stunning, my dear."

"Thanks, Papa," Arabella replied.

Emilio turned his attention to Theo, giving him a once-over. "And who is this?"

"This is Theo," Arabella said, her tone light but firm. "He's a friend of mine."

Theo extended his hand, meeting Emilio's gaze without flinching. "It's an honor to meet you, Mr. Armani."

Emilio shook his hand, his expression unreadable. "Likewise. Enjoy yourselves tonight."

As they stepped further into the ballroom, Sarah leaned in close to Arabella. "Okay, the tension back there? Palpable. Your dad has that whole 'intimidating father' thing down to a science."

Arabella laughed softly. "He's protective, that's all."

The night progressed smoothly, with Arabella and her friends mingling, sipping champagne, and enjoying the music. She felt a sense of pride as she looked around the room—this was her world, one she'd spent so much time trying to reconcile with her own desires.

But her sense of calm shattered the moment she saw him.

Alessio walked into the ballroom, his dark suit perfectly tailored to his tall, commanding frame. His presence was magnetic, and the energy in the room seemed to shift as eyes turned to him. But it wasn't just him.

Sophia was on his arm, her red gown clinging to her like it was designed to make a statement. She looked radiant, her dark curls cascading over her shoulders as she whispered something to Alessio, who gave her a curt nod in response.

Arabella froze, her breath catching in her throat.

Sarah, ever observant, followed her gaze and immediately frowned. "Oh no. You've got to be kidding me."

Theo glanced at her, concern etching his features. "Are you okay?"

Arabella forced herself to nod, though her heart felt like it was lodged in her throat. "I'm fine," she said, though the words rang hollow.

Alessio's eyes scanned the room, and when they landed on her, time seemed to stop. Their gazes locked, and for a moment, it felt like the world had fallen away. He looked at her like he always had—like she was the only thing in the room that mattered.

But then his expression hardened, and he turned away, leading Sophia deeper into the crowd.

Arabella exhaled shakily, gripping the edge of her glass. She refused to let him ruin her night. Not when she'd worked so hard to move forward.

"Let's dance," she said suddenly, turning to Theo.

Theo blinked, surprised, but nodded quickly. "Of course."

He led her to the dance floor, where couples swayed gracefully to the music. Arabella tried to focus on the rhythm, on Theo's gentle hands guiding her, but she could feel Alessio's presence like a shadow.

From across the room, Alessio watched them, his jaw tightening. Sophia leaned in, saying something he didn't register. His focus was entirely on Arabella—her smile, her laugh, the way she moved so effortlessly with another man.

It should have been easy to look away, to remind himself that she wasn't his anymore. But it wasn't.

As the night wore on, Arabella kept her head high, refusing to let Alessio's presence shake her. She laughed with her friends, danced with Theo, and pretended not to notice the way Alessio's eyes followed her every move.

But deep down, she knew the truth. No matter how far she tried to run from him, he would always have a part of her. And tonight had only made that harder to ignore.

As Arabella swayed on the dance floor with Theo, she let herself be carried by the music, the gentle rhythm guiding her movements. Theo's hands rested lightly on her waist, his demeanor kind and respectful, his soft smile helping her relax despite the tension coursing through her body.

"You're a natural at this," Theo said, his voice low enough to just reach her over the music.

Arabella chuckled. "You're just being polite. I've stepped on your foot twice."

"I didn't even notice," he replied, his grin widening.

For the first time that night, Arabella felt a bit of the weight lift from her chest. Dancing with Theo felt safe—simple and uncomplicated. He didn't know the depth of the chaos in her world, and for now, she liked it that way.

But as they spun lightly, Arabella's gaze drifted across the room, almost instinctively, and there he was—Alessio. He stood near the edge of the dance floor, one hand in his pocket, his dark eyes locked on her. His expression was unreadable, but there was a heat in his gaze that made her breath hitch.

Arabella quickly looked away, focusing back on Theo, who hadn't noticed the shift in her energy.

"This is nice," Theo said, his tone sincere. "I'm glad you invited me tonight."

She gave him a small smile, though her thoughts were elsewhere. "I'm glad you came."

As they continued to dance, Arabella couldn't shake the feeling of being watched. It was as though Alessio's presence filled the room, commanding her attention even when she tried to ignore it.

And then, as the song began to change, Alessio moved.

He crossed the dance floor with purpose, his presence parting the crowd like a tide. Arabella felt her chest tighten as he approached, his intense gaze never leaving hers.

Theo noticed him too, his steps faltering slightly as Alessio stopped beside them.

"Arabella," Alessio said, his voice smooth but tinged with something darker. "May I have this dance?"

Arabella froze, her heart pounding in her chest.

Theo glanced between them, clearly picking up on the tension. "We were just—"

"It's okay, Theo," Arabella interrupted softly, offering him a reassuring smile. She could feel Alessio's eyes burning into her, and as much as she wanted to say no, part of her knew she wouldn't. Not tonight.

Theo hesitated, his brow furrowing. "Are you sure?"

Arabella nodded, though her hands trembled slightly as she released his. "I'll be fine."

Theo stepped back reluctantly, giving Alessio a wary glance before disappearing into the crowd.

Alessio extended a hand to her, his expression unreadable but his presence overwhelming. Arabella hesitated for a moment before placing her hand in his. The moment their skin touched, a spark shot through her, the connection between them as electric as ever.

Without a word, Alessio pulled her closer, his hand settling firmly on her waist as the music shifted into a slow, melodic waltz.

"What are you doing, Alessio?" Arabella asked, her voice barely above a whisper.

"Dancing with you," he replied, his tone low and intimate.

"You shouldn't have come," she said, trying to keep her voice steady.

He smirked, though it didn't reach his eyes. "I didn't come here for you. But now that I'm here, I couldn't stay away."

Her jaw clenched, and she tried to step back, but his hold on her tightened slightly.

"You're making this harder than it needs to be," she said.

"Maybe," he admitted, his gaze softening for a moment. "But I needed to see you."

Arabella swallowed hard, her emotions warring within her. She wanted to push him away, to tell him he had no right to still have this effect on her. But the way he was looking at her made it impossible to breathe.

"Alessio," she began, her voice trembling, "we're not doing this. You're here with Sophia, remember?"

He flinched slightly at her words, but his grip on her didn't loosen. "Sophia doesn't mean anything to me, Arabella. You know that."

"Then why bring her?" she demanded, her frustration bubbling to the surface. "Why parade her around like she's—"

"Because I don't know how to stay away from you," he cut her off, his voice raw. "And I thought... I thought if I brought her, it would make it easier. But it doesn't. Nothing makes this easier."

Arabella stared at him, her resolve wavering. She wanted to tell him off, to remind him of all the reasons they couldn't be together. But instead, she let herself fall into the rhythm of the dance, her body betraying her as it moved in sync with his.

For a moment, it was just the two of them, the rest of the room fading away.

But reality came crashing back as the song ended, and Alessio reluctantly released her.

"I can't do this, Alessio," she whispered, stepping back.

He opened his mouth to respond, but before he could, Theo appeared at her side, his expression protective.

"Is everything okay?" Theo asked, his gaze flicking to Alessio.

Arabella nodded quickly, forcing a smile. "Yes. Let's go find Sarah and Carter."

Without looking back at Alessio, she took Theo's arm and let him guide her away, her heart heavy with emotions she wasn't ready to confront.

Alessio watched her go, his hands curling into fists at his sides. He had let her slip through his fingers once before. But this time, he wasn't sure if he could let her go.

The ball was still in full swing when Arabella found herself wandering away from the grand hall, the hum of music and laughter fading behind her. Her emerald gown swished softly around her legs as she trailed her fingers along the cool marble walls. She needed a moment to breathe, to shake the weight of the encounter with Alessio on the dance floor.

As she wandered deeper into the Castellano estate, she turned a corner and found herself in front of a set of tall, double doors slightly ajar. Curiosity got the better of her, and she pushed one of them open, stepping inside.

Her breath hitched.

The room was stunning—a private library bathed in warm, golden light from an ornate chandelier hanging above. Floor-to-ceiling shelves lined the walls, filled with countless books of every size and color, their spines creating a mosaic of history, knowledge, and art. In the center of the room was a plush, emerald-green loveseat, flanked by antique tables adorned with delicate lamps and crystal decanters.

Arabella stepped further in, her awe growing with each passing second. The space felt magical, like stepping into a storybook. She ran her fingers lightly over the spines of a row of books, the scent of aged pages and leather bindings filling the air.

"Beautiful, isn't it?"

The deep, familiar voice sent a shiver down her spine.

She turned quickly to see Alessio standing in the doorway, his broad shoulders framed by the warm glow of the library's lights. He looked impossibly handsome, his tie slightly loosened and his dark hair tousled as if he'd run his fingers through it in frustration.

"I didn't know anyone else was here," Arabella said, her voice quieter than she intended.

Alessio stepped inside, closing the door softly behind him. "I saw you leave the ballroom. I wanted to make sure you were okay."

Arabella crossed her arms, though it was more to steady herself than anything else. "I just needed some air. The ball's a bit... overwhelming."

He nodded, his eyes scanning the room before landing back on her. "This was always my favorite room in the house. It's quiet. Feels like a world away from everything else."

Arabella turned away, focusing on a particularly intricate volume on one of the shelves. "It's beautiful."

"It is," Alessio said, his voice softer now.

She felt him move closer, his presence wrapping around her like a cloak. She should have told him to leave, should have walked out herself. But she didn't.

"Arabella," he said, her name a plea on his lips.

She turned to face him, her resolve crumbling the moment their eyes met. There was something raw in his gaze, something vulnerable that she wasn't used to seeing from him.

"You shouldn't be here," she whispered, though her voice lacked conviction.

"Neither should you," he replied, taking a step closer.

Her heart pounded as the distance between them shrank. "Alessio—"

But before she could finish, he closed the space between them, his lips capturing hers in a kiss that stole her breath. It was desperate and consuming, like he was pouring every unspoken word, every buried feeling, into that single moment.

Arabella didn't push him away. Instead, she found herself leaning into him, her hands fisting the fabric of his jacket as he pulled her closer. The world outside the library ceased to exist—there was only him, only this.

"Tell me to stop," he murmured against her lips, his voice hoarse.

She couldn't. She didn't want to.

Instead, she kissed him again, her fingers sliding into his hair as he backed her gently toward the loveseat. The books, the chandelier, the rest of the world blurred as they gave in to the pull between them, a pull that had been building for far too long.

It wasn't just about desire—it was about the connection they'd tried so hard to sever, the emotions they'd buried beneath anger and pride. In that moment, it all came rushing back, raw and undeniable.

As they finally broke apart, their breaths ragged, Alessio rested his forehead against hers.

"This is wrong," Arabella whispered, though her hands still rested on his chest.

"It doesn't feel wrong," he replied, his voice thick with emotion.

She closed her eyes, her heart warring with her mind. She knew this couldn't last, that the complications between them were too great. But for now, in this room full of stories and secrets, she let herself believe that maybe, just maybe, they could rewrite their own.

Share This Chapter