Chapter 281

Chapter 281 ~SCARLETT~

My sister and best friend were not giving me a chance to breathe. They were throwing questions at me, one after the next.

I didn’t want to remember anything about last night. I wanted to forget last night ever happened.

“You need to tell us what happened last night between you and Carter!” Clara repeats as Jenna joins us in the car. It was the next day, and I was still in shock and scarred from last night, and it was all these two traitor’s fault.

They abandoned me when I needed them the most.

How could they have left me to deal with Carter on my own?

How could they let him drop me home?

“I can’t believe the two of you!” I snap. “You guys are such traitors. How could you let me leave with Carter all by myself? Do you even realize how awful that was for me?”

A part of me knew that wasn’t entirely true. It wasn’t completely awful, but that wasn’t something I was ready to admit.

Jenna gives me a sneaky smile, “it was Clara’s idea. She said it would be best for the two of you to leave together so that you could get closer to him. But did that happen? Did you happen to get closer to Carter?”

I sigh, “I knew my sister would be the one to throw me under the bus. She lives to see me in pain.”

Clara rolls her eyes, “stop being so dramatic.”

“Come on,” Jenna says impatiently. “You need to spill the tea. We want to know everything! And don’t leave a single detail out.”

I roll my eyes, “I shouldn’t tell you anything for abandoning me last night. I thought I would have died!”

“You’re being dramatic again!” Clara exclaims. “If you want to get closer to Carter, you’ll have to spend time alone with just the two of you. It’s something you have to get used to.”

“That’s the problem,” I snap. “I don’t want to get closer to him. I’m only doing this for you. Don’t I have a say in how I get closer to him?”

“No,” Clara answers me. “If we want him to fall in love with you, we must do things my way. If it were up to you, you wouldn’t try to get close to him and instead try to push him away.”

“I have a question for you,” I tell my sister. There is something that has been bothering me about last night. I wanted to know if I was wrong about Carter. “Did Carter ever open his truck door for you or any door?”

She laughs, “Come on, Scarlett. It’s Carter Prince. He doesn’t do romantic. Everyone knows this, including me, and I would know plenty since I dated him. But why do you ask?”, she pauses before her eyes widen. “Don’t tell me he did it for you?”

I’m not sure how to answer this question. On the one hand, my sister would be happy to know he was falling for me or at least pretending to fall for me. But on the other, she would be sad that he was so quick to care for me when he never did anything for her.

“It looked like he was going to, but I opened the door before, so I can’t say.” I lie to her. I’m unsure if I’m doing the right thing by lying to her, but I was scared of hurting her. She was going through enough already. I knew she didn’t choose the best way to deal with her heartache, but she was my sister, and she wasn’t a bad person. She’s never wished bad on anyone except Carter, but that was only because he hurt her first. And he did it in the worst way possible.

Whenever I think about what he’s done, I know I must continue with this plan.

“But are you ever going to tell us what happened?” Jenna asks; she seemed the most anxious to hear the stories I had to tell from last night.

“Carter saw me standing next to his truck from the pool area. He immediately came down to ask me what I was doing there. I explained that I might have been there to wreck his windshield for hurting Clara. Of course, he didn’t believe me because I’m apparently too nice even to break someone’s windshield or anything at all.”

Clara laughs, “Of course, you’re too nice for that. I’m happy you stood up for me, but I don’t think you should keep doing that around him. We want him to start liking you. You’ll need to try at least to be nice to him.”

I’m not sure my sister knows what she’s speaking about. Carter seemed to be treating me better when I acted mean to him. For some reason, it seemed like he liked it when I was mean to him.

“So what happened next?” Jenna asks me, still listening intently. “I feel like I’m reading a novel, but it’s your life! How cool is this?”

“Very cool,” I say dryly. “Something strange happened next. It makes me wonder what type of person Carter is. I felt like I saw another side to him last night.”

“What do you mean?” Clara asks me as she tilts her head to the side, trying to hear me better.

“I left him by his truck and was heading back inside, but two drunk guys were by the entrance. They tried to harass me, and one even touched my ass. Of course, I slapped him, but then they tried to attack me, and that’s when Carter stepped in. I could have handled it independently, but he still showed up. He smashed their faces to the ground and asked them to apologize. After they did, he told them to remember my name and never to try anything like that again on me. Then he gave me his shirt to cover up my body so that no other guys tried to interfere with me again. And if that surprises you, there’s more. I told him that I was heading back inside, but he insisted that I go back to his truck. When I said no, he picked me up and threw me over his shoulder, and carried me back to his truck.” I tell them.

I wait for a response, but they’re both reticent. It freaks me out since they’re always so noisy, especially when talking about Carter.

“Aren’t you going to say something?” I ask.

Clara shakes her head at me, “I feel like you’re talking about a different person.” She admits. “Are you sure that was Carter and not one of his brothers that resembles him?”

“I wish!” I exclaim, “But it was definitely him. No one else.”

“That’s crazy,” Jenna says. “I would not expect something like that from Carter. But this means that Clara’s plan is working. He’s beginning to care for you, and we haven’t even tried hard enough yet.”

What did she mean by that? I was trying pretty freaking hard. They weren’t the ones putting their lives on the line like me. Of course, it would seem like nothing for both of them.

“We need to see his reaction to you at school today,” Clara says. “I need to figure out if he’s messing with you or falling. I’m not sure how we will be able to tell, but we just have to wait and see.”

How wonderful, another day of seeing Carter Prince!