Cravings

LEVI

~“I’m still a virgin.”~

In a whisper, Madison had just revealed something very personal to them.

Something surprising, but not at all unwelcome.

It just meant they needed to take things slow.

Ethan had told him what she’d said about Daniel: that she’d never had sex with him. But somehow it had never crossed their minds that she hadn’t had sex at all.

Madison opened her eyes, but kept them lowered—locked on her fingers, which were playing with the stem of her glass.

“Madison,” Levi said gently.

“Blanca, look up,” Ethan repeated, more firmly.

For some reason, Levi’s twin brother had always had a strange sort of control over Madison. Though it obviously annoyed her at times, she still usually did as he asked.

And sure enough, she slowly raised her chin. She met Levi’s eyes first.

“There is nothing to be ashamed of, ’Flake,” he assured her.

“On the contrary, we’re very happy,” Ethan agreed. “Though we wouldn’t have minded either way.”

As they often did, they took turns speaking, as if they had one shared mind and knew exactly what the other would say.

Levi leaned in, approaching her from the front, while Ethan’s arms wrapped around her side to pull her into his chest.

With his index finger, Levi traced Madison’s profile until his thumb was close to her lips. He played with them for a second before meeting them with his own.

His free hand wandered higher up her leg and slid under her dress, moving up until he reached her inner thigh.

When his fingers reached the warmth between her legs, a gasp escaped her lips, and the moment they parted, he deepened the kiss, interlacing his tongue with hers.

They breathed as one, and Madison shifted in the booth, leaning back against Ethan.

Levi could feel her panties becoming wet, and she moaned softly when Ethan cupped the side of her breast.

Savoring every bit of her mouth, Levi trailed his finger from her face down her neck.

She shuddered and tightened her legs, trapping his other hand between them.

He brushed his fingers against the damp fabric, letting out a low, guttural groan as he did, then sucked on her bottom lip and released it, leaving her pouting.

MADISON

Before she knew what was happening, Ethan was turning her so she was facing him.

Levi’s hands were pulled away from their position to land on her waist, while Ethan’s took over the empty spot on her thighs.

At the hungry look in his eyes, she worried her bottom lip.

“Don’t do that, little ’Flake,” Ethan whispered against her nose.

His husky voice made her shiver, and his sexy smirk made her want to do just the opposite.

She sank her teeth into her lip again, and a second later, his mouth was on hers.

But instead of kissing her, he captured her bottom lip between his own teeth and bit it gently.

The way he bit and sucked her lip, letting his tongue slide around the edge of her mouth, was something she had never felt before, and it was a huge turn-on.

~Good lord, he is good.~

She could feel her panties getting wetter as Ethan slid his tongue between her lips, demanding access.

Surprising her, Levi nuzzled into her neck and kissed it softly.

The combined sensations were almost too much to handle, but she gave in to the kiss, tangling her tongue with Ethan’s and hanging on to both of them for dear life.

She heard footsteps approaching, and the three of them pulled apart just in time, right before the waiter pulled the curtains aside.

The twins looked fine, like nothing had happened, but Madison was convinced everything they’d done was written all over her face.

The waiter didn’t seem to notice anything though, just asked if they were ready to order.

“I’ll have a steak, please,” Levi said.

“Make that two, please, and another round of drinks,” Ethan added.

Madison just smiled at the waiter for a few seconds while she tried to clear her head. “Um, sorry. I’ll take the seafood salad, please.”

The waiter disappeared as quickly as he’d arrived.

“You guys are bad,” Madison muttered, still trying to catch her breath.

Ethan chuckled. “Are we?”

“Mm-hmm.” She nodded, noticing that goosebumps covered her skin.

Levi’s hand found a soft place on her inner thigh, very close to her happy place. “But I’ll risk it and say that you like it.”

She inhaled deeply and parted her legs just a tiny bit.

“I do. It’s also all…so new,” she replied.

Ethan put his hands on her shoulders and started to massage them. “Let me ask you something, ’Flake. When I came to pick you up from college, you said you’d never had sex with that douchebag.

“But is he the only one you’ve been intimate with?”

His look was so genuine that she smiled at him before she turned to look at Levi, who seemed just as curious.

“Yeah. He was the only one.”

“Interesting. I guess we just assumed otherwise,” Levi admitted.

“You never asked.”

Ethan cocked his head. “And what did you try with him?”

“Not much, actually. Definitely nothing like I’m experiencing now.”

“Really? But we’ve only kissed.”

“Yes. And I feel more kissing you than being touched by D—”

Levi tapped her mouth before she could finish Daniel’s name, shaking his head.

“And what is it you’re feeling?” he asked.

She swallowed hard and licked her lips, opening her legs a bit more.

Levi’s fingers were so close to her core that she was sure he could feel the heat emanating from it.

“I think you can easily guess,” she teased.

Ethan’s fingers brushed the side of her breast as he kissed her neck. “We want to hear it from you, Madison.”

But before she could work out what she wanted to say, they heard the waiter’s footsteps again, this time with their food.

Levi withdrew his hand and winked at her. “We’ll talk later.”

***

Dinner passed quickly.

The boys gave Madison a break and teased each other instead, and they all had the chance to discover new things about each other.

When they left, before they got into the car, Madison got on her tiptoes to kiss first Ethan and then Levi softly on their lips, feeling almost like a teenager.

Seriously, she could spend her whole night just kissing them.

“Dinner was amazing, guys. Thank you.”

“It’s not over yet, ’Flake. We still have a lot to talk about,” Ethan said.

Madison pouted. “Are we only going to talk?”

“We’ll see, shall we?”

Levi took the driver’s seat this time, and Ethan sat behind him.

Madison put her hand on Levi’s hard thigh as he drove them out of the parking lot. “Can I ask you something?”

“Anything.”

“Have you done this before?”

“Been with the same girl, you mean?”

“Yes,” she said quietly, afraid of the answer despite, or maybe because of, what she’d seen.

Levi smiled before taking her hand in his and placing a soft kiss on her knuckles.

“Yes, but only for sex. We’ve never dated the same girl before.”

“So this is going to be our first time as well,” Ethan added.

“So why now? Why me?”

Ethan leaned forward so that his face was next to hers, then moved a few stray curls away from her face and tucked them behind her ear, making her melt.

“Because we know you and you know us,” he explained. “Better than anyone else.”

“When you came back from college that first summer,” Levi added, “we felt different toward you. It’s hard to explain.”

Ethan wound a curl around his finger. “We felt physical attraction, of course, but it wasn’t just that. It could never be just sex—not with you. But you were so young, and you thought of us like brothers, so we kept away.”

“And now that we know you were still so innocent, we’re even more glad we did,” Levi assured her.

“We talked about it a lot these past few weeks, because we didn’t know how you would react to the idea of two men, and we definitely didn’t want to fuck up our friendship with your brothers, or you.

“Honestly, we were planning to ignore the attraction. But the night of the bonfire, we realized our feelings went much deeper than mere attraction. And then after the truth or dare kiss, we just couldn’t help ourselves. We had to try,” Ethan finished.

Madison chuckled, tilting her head slightly to reach Ethan’s fingers, where she left a sweet kiss. “I’m happy you tried. Because I was feeling it too,” she admitted.

Ethan planted one last kiss on her cheek and leaned back as Levi pulled into her driveway behind her brothers’ cars.

“I guess I should go in alone,” she said, sighing. “I’m not sure my brothers would buy the fact that you not only drove me to my date, you brought me home as well.”

A small pout crossed her face, and the twins both laughed.

“You’ll see us soon, ’Flake,” Levi promised, leaning forward to leave a soft kiss on her lips.

“Sleep tight,” Ethan said, with a kiss of his own.

Reluctantly, Madison got out of the car, looking at the two men one more time before waving and blowing kisses.

She turned and quickly walked up the driveway, then went around and snuck in the side door to avoid her brothers.

Usually she wouldn’t mind staying up and talking to them—but ~usually~ she didn’t sneak around behind their backs and date their best friends, either. Plus, right now she had other needs on her mind.

Once in her bathroom, she washed her face and brushed her teeth before taking off her dress and still-soaked panties.

She walked back into her room and slipped on silky pajamas before getting into her bed. But before her head hit the pillow, her phone lit up.

Levi

Are you still awake?

Ethan

We just got home.

Madison

Good. I just got in bed.

Ethan

You looked disappointed when we left you.

Madison

I guess I just wasn’t ready for the night to end

Ethan

You should have said something

Levi

We didn’t want to overwhelm you on our first date.

Madison

So for the second day in a row you left me…and my cravings…alone

Ethan

And what is it that you’re craving?

Madison

I guess that’s for you to find out next time

Levi

Madison…

Madison

Good night boys, sleep well

Levi

Yeah, good night Flake

Ethan

Sleep tight

With a big smile on her face, Madison put her phone on the nightstand then rolled on her back. She took a deep breath and released it.

Right now, all she wanted was for them to be there with her, to feel their hands discovering every inch of her body, exploring the most intimate parts of her.

After a night of such sexual tension, it wasn’t a surprise that the moment her fingers were under her shorts, she found her folds already dripping wet.